From Adriatico's to Trophy, here are Cincinnati's best leftover pizzas
HomeHome > News > From Adriatico's to Trophy, here are Cincinnati's best leftover pizzas

From Adriatico's to Trophy, here are Cincinnati's best leftover pizzas

Oct 15, 2023

If you're reading this, you have likely warmed up leftover pizza countless times. But is there a certain pizza that reheats better than others?

Five Enquirer pizza experts sought to find the best leftover pizza in Cincinnati, as part of our Reheated Eats series. We picked the restaurants based on how much we like them and their convenience to the busyness of our everyday lives (so yes, we admittedly missed some notable pizzerias). All of us then warmed up our choices (plus one extra Cincinnati chili pizza for funsies) and rated each pie out of five.

The restaurants we decided on were Chameleon Pizza, Trophy Pizza, Adriatico's, Catch-a-Fire Pizza and Taglio Bar + Pizzeria. Here is how they fared. The final rankings were based on each pizza's average rating. The person who brought the pizza in also gave their thoughts.

Think we should do this again with the pizzerias we missed? Let us know which restaurants you want us to try in the comments.

It's happened:Cincinnati finally has a real, authentic New York-style pizza joint

Reheated Eats part 1:Which local restaurant has the best leftover tacos? We put 5 to the test 🌮

It's happened: Reheated Eats part 1: Restaurant address Price: Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts Restaurant address Price Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts Restaurant address Price Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts Restaurant address Price Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts Restaurant address Price Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts Restaurant address Price Ingredients Notes Overall rating Final thoughts